×
×

oversimplification

Q: Can anyone explain the phenomenon of public opinion? It seems like as soon as a popular opinion emerges a bunch of people just instantly agree A: I'd encourage you to watch Joshua: Teenager vs. Superpower A lot of people are inspired to believe in something because of how intriguing it is to think about when it is suggested. A good example is the above statement. Most people would read it and just agree. I pulled it out of my arse, I have no stats to back it up. But it seems believable because it would be intriguing if people were just getting intrigued enough to believe in something. Take for example on of the core principles of the Scientific Method: Ockham's Razor (as it has become, not what it originally was). "When multiple theories explain the evidence, the one that makes the least assumptions should be chosen", often similarly stated as "keep it simple stupid". Well, my rebuttal to that is, "I'm not surprised that a simple person would think simpler is better", and I would cite my experimental research studying the friction of metals with and without various lubricants at various angles of elevation. In this experiment we had blocks of metal sitting on a lever that would be carefully raised until the metal slid down the lever. The angle was recorded and the experiment repeated. The equation for friction has long been 'known' and we had been taught it 3 or so years earlier. Now, the key piece of evidence we brought to the table was that in rare situations the lubricated block would remain stuck to the lever even beyond a 90 degree angle, yep, beyond the vertical. In the write-up for the experimental report, we had to declare these datapoints as 'outliers' to show that our 'learning outcomes' had been achieved for the class. When in actuality, one of the simplest equations and easiest procedures to verify was utterly bullshit. Sure, maybe after 1000 experiments we might produce an average that has a significant difference between lubricants to show that indeed as the lubricant is defined, the oil should decrease the friction (we weren't told if it decreased static or dynamic friction, simply that it decreases friction). It was through this simple experiment that I learnt that "keep it simple stupid" doesn't mean "keep it simple unless you want to be an idiot", it means "keep it simple, if you are an idiot." So to the modern version of Ockham's Razor proponents I say "when multiple theories explain the evidence, the one that makes the least assumptions is the simplest but not necessarily the best. But, of course, this is just a simplification." I regularly read scientific articles and deny their conclusions, reasoning and methods. And back to the crowd dynamics, for me to explain why people see a popularism as an "all aboard" sign to get on the bus, would require explaining why people with a common background education make common leaps in reasoning. Basically, it's because we've all been fenced in to ideas like "God is good, doubt is a sin", or it's alternative "god is man-made, skepticism is rational", or it's alternative "everything is everything", or "it is what it is" or "don't take it at face value". I'm the type of person that has the sneaking suspicion that following the theories with the least assumptions takes an eternity to converge on complete knowledge. But that's just a theory with only one assumption, that the conclusion is true. Another good film to watch is Mother! 2017. The main character, Jennifer Lawrence, is faced with that. It's the writer's exploration of that 'public opinion' phenomenon. The concept of the 'public' isn't all that old. Another facet of it, is that people's news on TV, newspaper and online is curated by popularity. So once something becomes popular enough to be seen, it's now easier for it to become more poular.

Viewcount: 616
Post viewcount: 60969 Views

abstracting metaphor

Viewcount: 693

a letter to a consciousness

Viewcount: 939

a letter to a nihilist

Viewcount: 850

a letter to a politician

Viewcount: 689

a letter to a square

Viewcount: 698

any years resolution

Viewcount: 870

axioms empty set

Viewcount: 798

Beliefs be leaves on a tree

Viewcount: 1029

Birthday Requests

Viewcount: 396

building sandcastles

Viewcount: 712

case reports

Viewcount: 643

cleaning up after priors

Viewcount: 652

cognitive fallacies

Viewcount: 669

creating morality

Viewcount: 715

dear god

Viewcount: 679

escaping from reality

Viewcount: 706

ever present metaphors

Viewcount: 625

every story as a story

Viewcount: 902

explore the body

Viewcount: 679

freedom as a negative concept

Viewcount: 612

front

Viewcount: 615

future human sex

Viewcount: 770

gnosis

Viewcount: 962

god a non npc

Viewcount: 983

having the drug talk

Viewcount: 711

her

Viewcount: 693

hermeneutics - interpretation

Viewcount: 745

hitchen's razor

Viewcount: 1222

how can i learn more about psychoactive drugs

Viewcount: 639

how does good

Viewcount: 779

how i meditate where it gets me

Viewcount: 734

how psychedelic wake

Viewcount: 840

humorism

Viewcount: 759

hypotheticals

Viewcount: 599

if singularity, then end of the world

Viewcount: 606

incompatibility

Viewcount: 700

Internet of babel

Viewcount: 618

In The Beginning

Viewcount: 767

is it wrong to think the wrong thing

Viewcount: 577

line

Viewcount: 736

mental guises

Viewcount: 589

mental hospital

Viewcount: 597

miraculous is magic

Viewcount: 685

muhammad

Viewcount: 690

my first trip

Viewcount: 796

my second trip

Viewcount: 641

occam's gear

Viewcount: 786

on existence of equality

Viewcount: 543

other

Viewcount: 626

Out of context

Viewcount: 582

oversimplification

Viewcount: 616

perhaps rest in peace is wrong

Viewcount: 636

podcast reviews

Viewcount: 776

projection bias

Viewcount: 800

proverbs are i told you so's

Viewcount: 752

psychedelics and suicide

Viewcount: 671

purposeful misreading

Viewcount: 605

p vs np

Viewcount: 1021

questions about a trip

Viewcount: 734

quotes of the aether

Viewcount: 563

reactionary mindfulness

Viewcount: 557

responsibilities for parents

Viewcount: 676

skeptic

Viewcount: 713

suicide preventiono

Viewcount: 610

tachyons

Viewcount: 676

taking a step back

Viewcount: 601

tautology as magic

Viewcount: 638

the anything innate difference

Viewcount: 645

the house of want

Viewcount: 593

the limit of outside the box thinking

Viewcount: 627

the meaning of life

Viewcount: 624

-- the synthing

Viewcount: 644

the system is rigged

Viewcount: 620

thought police

Viewcount: 781

to make a parody of yourself

Viewcount: 652

to say

Viewcount: 606

trickledown economics

Viewcount: 618

trip 3

Viewcount: 617

trip 4

Viewcount: 632

tying up loose ends

Viewcount: 764

ultimately containing complete greediness

Viewcount: 591

What is meaning? Every word could mean anything if said on it's own, in particular: sex.

Viewcount: 616

what is the meaning of life

Viewcount: 633

who am i

Viewcount: 703

why psychedelic wake

Viewcount: 670

woo woo

Viewcount: 780

you're not going to notice it

Viewcount: 762